The Culturally Responsive Measurement Tool: Protective Factors (CRMT-PF) – UNDER CONSTRUCTION
The Culturally Responsive Measurement Tool – Protective Factors (CRMT-PF) is an instrument designed to measure protective factors in families with young children. The tool was adapted from the Protective Factors Survey Version 2 (PFS-2) from the FRIENDS National Resource Center for Community-Based Child Abuse Prevention. It was updated with the support of the Resilient Families Advisory Council between 2020 and 2022 to ensure the instrument was culturally responsive for diverse families in King County, It has been community validated in English to support the work of early learning programs serving King County families with children under the age of five.
Since 2020, Best Starts for Kids has been working with The Capacity Collective to develop the CRMT-PF for organizations in King County to use, with the goal of developing a culturally relevant, multilingual tool to measure protective factors for families with children under the age of five. Best Starts for Kids hopes the tool will be used to build evidence for community-designed, home-based services impact, and more largely to demonstrate the value of culturally responsive evaluation for other large systems-change or publicly funded initiatives. Throughout the three years of this project, The Capacity Collective and Best Starts for Kids have shared back findings with families who have tested the survey, advisory council members, and the larger King County community.
In 2020, The Capacity Collective convened an advisory council (the first Resilient Families Advisory Council) to begin the process of reviewing and revising the Protective Factors Survey Version 2 (PFS-2). The RFAC members came from the key communities that Best Starts for Kids identified (see below for a list), with more than one person per community represented to minimize burden. Members were from service-providing organizations within and outside of the BSK ecosystem; were compensated, both monetarily and with opportunities for professional development; and were a blend of direct service and program management staff.
In 2021, after the initial revisions provided by the first RFAC, a second RFAC was convened to lead a community-based validation process with the new instrument. This process was multi-tiered and involved qualitative feedback in the form of focus groups as well as statistical validation.
This year, the English language version of the tool is undergoing a pilot implementation with two community-based organizations. The results of this pilot implementation will inform the tools that The Capacity Collective develops to support organizations in implementing the CRMT-PF. Best Starts for Kids and The Capacity Collective also hopes to translate and validate the CRMT-PF into four additional languages in 2023; Spanish, Somali, Simplified Chinese, and Vietnamese.
Who Should Use the CRMT-PF?
- Early Learning Programs
- Programs serving families with children under the age of five
- Programs that want to focus on family strengths rather than deficits
- Programs wanting to understand their client’s current support systems
- Programs wanting to understand change in support systems over time in program
Why Should We Use the CRMT-PF?
- The CRMT-PF is the only assessment of its kind that has been community validated for use with diverse communities, such as those who live in King County.
- The CRMT-PF gives programs (and the county) a snapshot of how families are doing, and where more supports may be needed. During the validation process we heard from community that the tool was a great conversation starter.
- The CRMT-PF helps programs measure impacts on protective factors to see if they are building resilience in families they serve.
When should we use the CRMT-PF?
- The CRMT-PF is meant to be used at intake, or early in a family’s enrollment in a program, then again at the end of engagement. This gives programs an opportunity to see if there has been a change in protective factors during their time in the program.
- For programs that are multiple years, the CRMT-PF can be given at regular intervals, such as 6 months or 1 year, to monitor change in protective factors over time more regularly.
- For short programs, the CRMT-PF can be given at the start of the program to provide a snapshot of the family’s protective factors, including support systems. The tool can help identify immediate needs to support referrals to other programs or resources.
The English CRMT-PF was community validated between 2020 and 2022 with key communities identified by King County:
- Black & African American
- Indigenous/American Indian/Alaska Native
- Hispanic or Latino/a/x
- Asian (Chinese, Vietnamese)
- African (Somali, Ethiopian)
- Middle Eastern or North African
- Pacific Islander
- Families of children with special needs
The English CRMT-PF is currently undergoing an implementation study with the support of two Community-Based Organizations serving families in King County. This study will help The Capacity Collective ensure the implementation of the CRMT-PF into programs will be culturally-responsive for families, and be both meaningful and easy-to-use for the programs who will use the instrument. The results of this study will be available in July 2023.
Coming Soon: More Languages!
The CRMT-PF is currently undergoing a community validation process to test the instrument in four additional languages:
- Simplified Chinese
After the Community Validation process, the Somali, Spanish, Simplified Chinese and Vietnamese CRMT-PF instruments will go through an Implementation Study to ensure the integration of the instrument into programs is as culturally-responsive as the instrument itself. Implementation materials (such as the Implementation Guide and Scoring Tool) will be adapted and translated to support the CRMT-PF in each language.
Thank you to the many individuals and organizations who made the development and testing of this instrument possible!
- 2021 Resilient Families Advisory Council
- 2022 Resilient Families Advisory Council
- FRIENDS National Center for Community-Based Child Abuse Prevention
- Community-Based Organizations in and around King County
- Reviewers at King County
- Dr. Susan Spieker and Dr. Monica Oxford, University of Washington Barnard Center
- Debbie Peterson, Center for the Study of Social Policy
- Audrey Royston and Araceli Efigenio
More About the CRMT-PF
- Presented at the National Home Visiting Summit, March 2022
- Poster (English)
- Poster (Spanish)
- Presented at the American Evaluation Association, November 2022